The Stone Shields Show: Cincinnati Bengals, Reds, Bearcats Daily Sports Talk

Bengals Season Mercifully Ends, Zac Taylor & Duke Tobin Will Officially Return In 2026, Ohio State's Collapse

On today's show, we discuss Cincinnati's loss to the Browns as the 2025 season mercifully comes to an end, plus Mike Brown released a statement officially announcing Zac Taylor and Duke Tobin's return for the 2026 season. Also, we break down the College Football Playoff quarterfinals in what was an all-time choke job for Ohio State.
Yesterday, in what was essentially a meaningless Week 18 matchup for both clubs, the Cincinnati Bengals fell to the Cleveland Browns 20–18 at Paycor Stadium to close out a disappointing 2025 campaign.
Both teams entered the game already eliminated from playoff contention, but Cincinnati still hoped to end on a high note against an AFC North rival. Early on, Cincinnati struggled to put together consistent offense and committed costly errors, including missing two extra-point attempts — mistakes that would loom large in the final score. Meanwhile, Cleveland’s defense made a huge early impact, even scoring on a 97-yard interception return to set the tone.
The defining moment of the game came in the fourth quarter, when Browns defensive end **Myles Garrett not only pressured Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow but set the NFL’s single-season sack record with his 23rd sack. The celebration around that milestone was controversial — Bengals head coach **Zac Taylor angrily protested after officials paused play to honor Garrett’s achievement in a critical late-game moment.
Cincinnati mounted a late comeback, with Joe Burrow leading a quick scoring drive that gave the Bengals an 18–17 lead with under two minutes left. But Cleveland responded, and Shedeur Sanders engineered a clutch drive that set up Andre Szmyt’s 49-yard field goal as time expired to win it for the Browns.
For the Bengals, this loss capped a 6–11 season filled with inconsistency, turnovers, and missed opportunities. With Sunday’s defeat now in the books, Cincinnati will turn its focus to the offseason and making changes to get back into playoff contention in 2026.
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Holy (Trap).
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Exercise (Rock).
#Bengals #NFL #TheStoneShieldsShow

Al Golden Praising Geno Stone? Amarius Mims Continues To Impress, College Football Playoff Quarterfinals Preview

On today's show, we discuss some head-scratching remarks from Al Golden on Geno Stone plus discuss Amarius Mims' year 2 growth as he looks to be a future stud. Also, we preview all 4 CFP quarterfinals matchups, including Ohio State vs. Miami tonight.
Cincinnati Bengals defensive coordinator Al Golden publicly defended safety Geno Stone ahead of the Week 18 game, offering a relatively positive evaluation of the veteran despite widespread criticism of Stone’s play this season. Golden highlighted Stone’s leadership and communication as key factors in the defense’s improved performance over the past eight games, suggesting that Stone has played an important role in helping the unit find its footing of late. Golden credited him with getting the secondary aligned properly and being a stabilizing voice on the field.
Golden explicitly pointed to Stone’s contributions to recent defensive success, saying that much of the late-season improvement can be traced back to the safety’s steady presence. He acknowledged that both he and Stone, along with teammate Jordan Battle, would like to have “one play back here, one play back there,” but maintained that Stone has improved from the previous year and continues to develop. Golden emphasized a positive outlook on Stone’s future, stating he sees a “path forward” for Stone to keep improving with continued coaching.
It’s notable that while Golden praised Stone’s intangibles and leadership, he stopped short of committing to wanting Stone back in 2026, deflecting future-oriented questions by focusing solely on the final game of the season. Stone is set to become an unrestricted free agent, and Golden didn’t directly address plans for next year.
Golden’s comments have drawn mixed reactions, with many fans seeing his praise as coach-speak protecting a struggling player, while others interpret it as a genuine belief in Stone’s value beyond traditional statistical performance.
In short, Golden is publicly backing Geno Stone as a leader and communicator with room to grow, even as broader analysis and fan sentiment remain skeptical.
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Holy (Trap).
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Exercise (Rock).
#Bengals #NFL #TheStoneShieldsShow

Jason Williams On Bengals Offseason, Start Or Sit Joe Burrow? NFL Power Rankings, Rams Fall On MNF

On today's show Stone is joined by Jason Williams of The Enquirer and they discuss the upcoming Bengals offseason, whether Joe Burrow should start or sit vs. the Browns, the Reds potentially still being in on Luis Robert despite recent additions and more. Also, we roll through Stone's NFL Power Rankings going into the final week of the NFL regular season and react to the Rams getting upset in Atlanta on Monday Night Football.
Zac Taylor’s decision to play his starters, including quarterback Joe Burrow, in the final game of the season against the Cleveland Browns was a choice that sparked debate among fans and analysts. At the surface level, resting key players in a meaningless or low-stakes finale can seem like the safer option, especially when considering injury risk. However, Taylor’s approach reflected a broader philosophy about competitiveness, culture, and preparation.
One major factor behind the decision was momentum. Ending the season on a strong note can matter, particularly for a team trying to reinforce confidence and consistency. By playing Burrow and other starters, Taylor signaled that every game counts, regardless of playoff implications. This mindset helps establish a culture where effort and accountability do not fluctuate based on circumstance. For a franchise that has worked to shed years of inconsistency, maintaining that standard is significant.
There was also a developmental and rhythm-based argument. Burrow, coming off a demanding season, benefits from staying in sync with his receivers and offensive line. Game reps cannot be fully replicated in practice, and extended time off before the postseason—or the offseason—can disrupt timing. Taylor likely believed that keeping the offense sharp outweighed the controlled risk of limited snaps.
Critics, however, pointed to the obvious downside: injury. The Browns, a divisional rival, play a physical brand of football, and exposing franchise players in a final-week matchup always carries danger. For some, the potential long-term cost to Burrow’s health was not worth the short-term benefits.
Ultimately, Taylor’s decision highlighted his trust in his players and his commitment to a competitive identity. While reasonable minds can disagree on the risk-reward balance, the choice aligned with a coaching philosophy that prioritizes preparation, toughness, and treating every game as meaningful.
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Holy (Trap).
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Exercise (Rock).
#Bengals #NFL #TheStoneShieldsShow

Bengals Go Back To Back, Cody Ford Reception, Browns Upset Steelers, 49ers Stay Hot

On today's show we discuss the Bengals putting together another complete performance where the defense made some plays and Joe Burrow showcased his brilliance. Should the Bengals consider extending DJ Turner and Chase Brown? Also, Steelers upset by Browns, Eagles outlast Bills & 49ers stay hot.
In a convincing home performance at Paycor Stadium, the **Cincinnati Bengals cruised to a 37-14 victory over the Arizona Cardinals, never trailing and dominating across all three phases of the game.
Quarterback Joe Burrow was the catalyst for Cincinnati’s offense, throwing for 305 yards and two touchdown passes to star wide receiver Ja’Marr Chase. Burrow’s efficient performance tied the franchise record for most 300-yard passing games (28), previously held by Andy Dalton.
Chase was a constant threat, hauling in seven catches for 60 yards and both of his scores. With this outing, he became the first player in NFL history to record at least 80 receptions, 1,000 receiving yards, and seven touchdowns in each of his first five seasons, a remarkable milestone reflecting his elite consistency.
The Bengals also got a strong ground game from Chase Brown, who finished with 101 rushing yards and two rushing touchdowns, helping Cincinnati take control early and keep the Cardinals on their heels.
Cincinnati’s offense was so dominant that Burrow came out in the fourth quarter, with backup Joe Flacco taking over as the victory was well in hand. The Bengals amassed over 400 yards of total offense, showcasing balance and explosive playmaking. 
Despite the loss, the Cardinals had a highlight when tight end Trey McBride set the NFL single-season reception record for a tight end with 119 catches, giving Arizona a rare positive takeaway.
Cincinnati improves to 6-10 on the season with the win, while Arizona falls to 3-13, extending a tough campaign.
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Holy (Trap).
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Exercise (Rock).
#Bengals #NFL #TheStoneShieldsShow

Xavier Hoops With Shelby Dermer, Bengals 2023 Draft Class Shining? Bengals vs. Cardinals Preview, Best Bets Of The Weekend

On today's show, Stone talks Xavier basketball with Shelby Dermer who covers the Muskies for The Enquirer, as they discuss Year 1 for Richard Pitino and look ahead to the New Year's Eve matchup with UConn. Plus, is the Bengals' 2023 draft class actually really good? Also, we preview Sunday's Bengals vs. Cardinals tilt and roll through our Best Bets Of The Weekend.
The Cincinnati Bengals (5-10) host the Arizona Cardinals (3-12) this Sunday, December 28, 2025, at Paycor Stadium in Cincinnati for a 1:00 p.m. ET kickoff on FOX. Both teams are eliminated from playoff contention in disappointing 2025 seasons, turning this late-season matchup into a battle for pride, momentum heading into the offseason, and potentially better draft positioning.
The Bengals enter on a high note after exploding for 45 points in a dominant Week 16 win over the Miami Dolphins. Joe Burrow looked sharp in his return from injury, throwing for over 300 yards with multiple touchdowns, while Ja'Marr Chase and the offense clicked efficiently. Chase Brown added a strong rushing performance, and the unit showed flashes of the explosiveness that has defined Cincinnati in recent years. However, the defense remains a major concern, ranking near the bottom of the league in points allowed (30.5 per game) and struggling against the pass and tight ends.
Arizona, meanwhile, is mired in a seven-game losing streak, most recently falling 26-19 to the Atlanta Falcons. With Kyler Murray sidelined for the season due to injury, Jacoby Brissett has been under center, leading an inconsistent offense that relies heavily on tight end Trey McBride (over 1,000 yards and double-digit touchdowns). The Cardinals' run game has been decimated by injuries to backs like James Conner and Trey Benson, leaving Michael Carter as the primary option. Defensively, Arizona has been porous, allowing 30+ points in several recent games, though they can keep things close against vulnerable units. Bengals are favored by about 7 points, with a high over/under around 53.5, reflecting expectations of a potential shootout given both teams' defensive woes and offensive talent. Burrow's presence gives Cincinnati a clear edge at quarterback, and home-field advantage in cold December weather could trouble the dome-accustomed Cardinals.
Key storylines include Burrow continuing to build momentum post-injury, McBride's dominance against a Bengals defense weak vs. tight ends, and whether Arizona can snap their skid against a team with more natural talent. Experts largely side with Cincinnati, but the Cardinals' ability to move the ball through the air could keep it competitive.
In a "meaningless" game for standings, look for fireworks and individual performances to shine. Bengals are poised to win, likely covering in a high-scoring affair.
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Holy (Trap).
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Exercise (Rock).
#Bengals #NFL #TheStoneShieldsShow

Gordon Wittenmyer On Reds Potentially Trading For Luis Robert + More Offseason News, Dolphins Wild 2020 Trade Proposal To Bengals, NFL Power Rankings

On today's show Gordon Wittenmyer of The Enquirer joins Stone to discuss whether the Reds will trade for Luis Robert, Elly De La Cruz playing in the World Baseball Classic and more Reds offseason topics. Plus, we react to Adam Schefter's report on the Dolphins offering the Bengals 4 first round picks for the first overall selection in 2020 and roll through our NFL Week 17 Power Rankings:
The Cincinnati Reds could be one bold move away from becoming serious contenders, and a potential trade for Luis Robert Jr. might be exactly what they need. In this video, we break down the idea of the Reds trading for Luis Robert, what it would cost, and how he could instantly change the outlook of Cincinnati’s lineup.
Luis Robert is one of the most dynamic players in Major League Baseball, combining elite power, speed, and Gold Glove–caliber defense in center field. With the Chicago White Sox possibly entering a retooling phase, trade rumors are heating up around Robert, and the Cincinnati Reds are a team that makes a lot of sense as a potential landing spot. But would the Reds be willing to part with top prospects or young MLB talent to make this deal happen?
We’ll analyze how Luis Robert would fit into the Reds’ roster, how he complements stars like Elly De La Cruz and Matt McLain, and whether Cincinnati’s farm system gives them enough ammunition to pull off a blockbuster trade. We’ll also discuss contract details, injury concerns, and the overall risk vs. reward of making such a high-profile move.
If the Reds are serious about competing in the NL Central and making a deep playoff run, trading for a superstar like Luis Robert could be a franchise-altering decision. Is this the right time for Cincinnati to go all-in, or should they stay patient with their young core?
Let us know your thoughts in the comments: Should the Cincinnati Reds trade for Luis Robert? What would you give up to make the deal happen?
Don’t forget to like, subscribe, and turn on notifications for more Reds news, MLB trade rumors, and in-depth baseball analysis.
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Holy (Trap).
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Exercise (Rock).
#Bengals #Reds #TheStoneShieldsShow

Bengals Victory Monday, Big 3 Look The Part, CFP Round 1 Reaction, Steelers In Control Of AFC North

On today's show, we react to Cincinnati's 45-21 win over the Miami Dolphins and Stone explains why although this mean technically doesn't mean anything it was still important for Cincinnati as the "Big 3" finally looked the part this season. Also, we discuss Round 1 of the College Football Playoffs in what was not a good showing at all for the group of 5 schools + Aaron Rodgers turns back the clocks as Pittsburgh is on the precipice of a divisional title.
In a thrilling matchup, the Cincinnati Bengals delivered an explosive performance, defeating the Miami Dolphins 45-21. The Bengals showcased their offensive firepower, with standout plays and key contributions from both Joe Burrow and Ja'Marr Chase. Despite a strong first-half effort from Miami, the Dolphins struggled to keep pace as the Bengals' offense took control after halftime.
The game saw Quinn Ewers stepping in for a benched Tua Tagovailoa, and though Ewers showed flashes of potential, the Dolphins’ offense couldn’t find enough rhythm to match the Bengals’ high-powered attack. Joe Burrow was in top form, leading the Bengals with precision throws and timely decisions. Meanwhile, Ja'Marr Chase was dominant, consistently making big catches and proving why he’s one of the league’s top receivers.
On the defensive side, the Bengals did a great job of applying pressure and forcing mistakes, including key sacks and turnovers. Miami’s struggles to protect the quarterback, coupled with their inability to adjust to Cincinnati’s defensive schemes, kept the game out of reach. The Dolphins’ inability to capitalize on early opportunities ultimately led to their downfall.
This 45-21 win marks another strong statement for the Bengals as they continue to build momentum for the season. Watch the full game highlights and analysis to relive the key moments that led to this impressive victory!
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Holy (Trap).
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Exercise (Rock).
#Bengals #NFL #TheStoneShieldsShow

Bengals & Burrow Talk With Joe Danneman, College Football Weekend Preview, Bengals vs. Dolphins, Best Bets Of The Weekend

On today's show, Stone is joined by Joe Danneman of FOX19 Now, and they discuss all things Bengals, of course, including dissecting Joe Burrow and Zac Taylor's comments over the last two weeks. Plus we preview this weekend's slate of College Football Playoff games and roll through our Best Bets Of The Weekend.
The Cincinnati Bengals (4-10) close out their road slate Sunday in Miami against the Dolphins (6-8) in a game devoid of playoff implications for Cincy but rich with opportunity. After being officially eliminated from postseason contention, Zac Taylor’s club has a chance to build momentum into 2026 and reestablish competitive identity over the final three weeks.
Offensively, Joe Burrow and his talented receiving corps will look to bounce back from a tough shutout loss to Baltimore, where Burrow was held to 225 yards with two interceptions and Ja’Marr Chase still showed elite playmaking ability. Getting the offense untracked is priority one, and fresh legs in the passing game — particularly from Chase and whoever emerges as a No. 2 option — could exploit a Dolphins secondary missing playmakers at times.
Cincinnati’s defense, however, enters with concerns. The interior defensive line has taken hits with B.J. Hill and Kris Jenkins Jr. trending toward inactivity, and Joseph Ossai’s ankle issues further weaken pass-rush depth. That could challenge a Miami attack transitioning to rookie Quinn Ewers under center after benching Tua Tagovailoa amid a season leading the league in interceptions.
From a scheme standpoint, the Bengals can attack a Dolphins defense that has been inconsistent against the run and susceptible in the secondary — offering a blueprint for Cincinnati to sustain drives and flip field position. Turnovers and discipline will be key; forcing mistakes from an inexperienced Miami QB could tilt the game.
Ultimately, while the Bengals aren’t fighting for a playoff spot, Sunday serves as a referendum on effort, growth, and offseason trajectory. A strong road performance — especially in a physical division battle — can boost confidence and spotlight emerging core pieces heading into 2026.
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Holy (Trap).
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Exercise (Rock).
#Bengals #NFL #TheStoneShieldsShow

Cincinnati Bearcats Hoops With Terry Nelson, Jizzle James Return, Joe Burrow & Zac Taylor Comments, TNF Preview, Xavier Smacked At Home

On today's show, Stone is joined by Cincinnati Bearcats legend and radio analyst Terry Nelson to discuss UC's win last night, Jizzle James' return and more. Plus, we dive into Joe Burrow and Zac Taylor's comments at yesterday's press conference, tonight's huge NFC West matchup and Xavier's embarrassing loss at home to Creighton.
Ahead of Week 16 vs. the Miami Dolphins, Bengals QB Joe Burrow addressed the media with candid, reflective, and at times cryptic comments about his mindset, the season, and his future in the NFL.
In his opening remarks, Burrow made one thing clear: he still loves playing football. “I just want to play ball” was the overarching theme of his message — emphasizing that his passion for the game is what keeps him going, even through adversity. Burrow said it often feels like “everybody’s trying to do everything in their power to make me not play football,” but he’s fighting through it because he likes playing the game.
When asked about the possibility of playing elsewhere, Burrow gave an intriguing answer: “You think about a lot of things.”While he didn’t close the door on future possibilities, he also said he “can’t see a world in which he’s not with the Bengals in 2026.”
He reiterated that he expects to play for a long time, projecting confidence in his longevity and performance at a high level, even as this season has been one of setbacks and frustration.
Burrow also supported his coaches and teammates, suggesting that while changes might be needed, the organization has the right people in place — and that everyone wants the same thing: to win.
Subscribe for more Bengals updates and highlights!Follow for post-game reactions, locker room access, & weekly pressers
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Holy (Trap).
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Exercise (Rock).
#Bengals #NFL #TheStoneShieldsShow

Bengals Don't Care About Their Fans, Tua Benched For Sunday, Jizzle James Returns For UC, Xavier vs. Creighton

On today's show we discuss the Bengals not caring about their fans, Dianna Russini's comments on Joe Burrow, why the Bengals feel comfortable with Zac Taylor, Tua Tagovailoa being benched for Sunday's game, Jizzle James returning to the UC basketball team, Arch Manning committing to returning to Texas next season, Xavier vs. Creighton tonight and more!
Bengals news: Paul Dehner Jr.’s recent reporting suggests that, even after missing the playoffs for a third straight season and finishing with a 4-10 record, the Bengals are unlikely to make sweeping changes at the top of the football operations or coaching hierarchy. Internally, both Duke Tobin and Zac Taylor are expected to remain with the team heading into the 2026 season rather than being dismissed.
A key reason for this continuity is Tobin’s deeply rooted relationship with Bengals ownership. Dehner notes that Tobin—officially titled Director of Player Personnel but functioning as the de facto general manager—is regarded almost as part of the family by owner Mike Brown and the broader leadership structure. Because of this, ownership reportedly has no internal inclination to fire Tobin, even amid external pressure and fan frustration.
Taylor’s situation is similar in that his contractual status strongly favors retention. Dehner explains that Taylor is under contract through the 2027 season due to an additional extension that was not widely publicized at the time. Because the Bengals rarely fire head coaches with multiple years left on their deals, and given Taylor’s history leading the team to a Super Bowl and consecutive AFC Championship Games earlier in his tenure, his job is viewed as relatively secure.
In short, Dehner’s reporting paints a picture of ownership favoring stability and loyalty over dramatic change, even in the face of poor on-field results and vocal calls from the fan base for a reset. Both Tobin and Taylor are therefore expected to stay put for the foreseeable future.
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Holy (Trap).
Music from #InAudio: https://inaudio.org/Track Name Exercise (Rock).
#Bengals #NFL #TheStoneShieldsShow